Cricket Controversy: Warner–De Kock and the Tunnel Incident

Cricket Controversy: Warner–De Kock and the Tunnel Incident - During the 2018 Durban Test match, David Warner and Quinton de Kock were involved in an altercation that led to both players being fined by the ICC. The biggest impact of this incident was that it sparked a debate about the boundaries of acceptable behavior on the cricket field. Incidentally, the altercation took place off the field, during a break.

The Australian camp accused de Kock of making a comment about Warner's wife, which triggered Warner’s angry reaction. Let us look into the Test:

Match: 1st Test, Durban, March 1–5, 2018, Australia tour of South Africa

Australia 351 (M Marsh 96, Smith 56, Warner 51, Maharaj 5-123, Philander 3-59) & 227 (Bancroft 53, Maharaj 4-102, Morkel 3-47)
South Africa 162 (de Villiers 71*, Starc 5-34) & 298 (Markram 143, de Kock 83, Starc 4-75, Hazlewood 3-61)
Australia won by 118 runs
Player of the Match: Mitchell Starc (35, 5/34 & 4/75)

What led to the confrontation

In this first Test of the four-match series at Durban, Mitchell Starc missed out on a hat-trick, but Australia still won by 118 runs on the fifth morning, taking a 1-0 lead. With this win, Australia remained on course to maintain its remarkable record of not losing a Test series in South Africa since readmission.

However, news of an off-field altercation overshadowed Australia’s win, and the Test is remembered more for this incident than the result. The clash occurred during the tea interval on the fourth day, in the tunnel at Kingsmead. Only the players know exactly what happened, but cameras on the staircase leading to the dressing rooms recorded parts of the exchange, and this CCTV footage was later leaked by South African media outlet Independent Media.

The footage did not reveal who started the clash, but it showed Warner being physically restrained by some teammates while verbally attacking de Kock. Usman Khawaja and Tim Paine were seen urging Warner to move inside, before captain Steve Smith dragged his vice-captain away. South African skipper Faf du Plessis also tried to defuse the situation.

Both camps presented their own versions. South Africa’s management claimed the verbal exchanges began while de Kock was batting and continued off the field. However, umpires Kumar Dharmasena and S Ravi stated they had not heard anything offensive. Du Plessis still believes that if the umpires had intervened earlier, the tunnel confrontation could have been avoided.

Australia’s frustration was visible — they had taken only one wicket between lunch and tea, while de Kock and Aiden Markram were building a strong partnership, closing in on the 417-run target. Earlier in the day, another incident had taken place when Warner ran out AB de Villiers after a mix-up with Markram and celebrated by yelling in Markram’s direction. Warner was not charged for this, but bowler Nathan Lyon was penalized for throwing the ball near de Villiers.

South Africa insisted Warner had gotten personal, but Australia wicketkeeper Tim Paine claimed this was untrue, insisting Warner had not made personal remarks involving de Kock’s family. Conversely, Australia captain Steven Smith said de Kock’s comments to Warner were personal and crossed the line, even mentioning Warner’s wife.

Warner himself alleged that de Kock made a "vile and disgusting" comment about his wife, which triggered his anger in the tunnel. He said:
 

"I cop it left, right, and center, especially off the field from spectators, and I’m used to that — it doesn’t bother me. But when, in close proximity, and from behind me, a comment is made that is vile and disgusting about my wife — and, in general, about a lady — I felt it was very poor."
Although restrained by four teammates, Warner insisted he had no intention of getting physical with de Kock.

What happened thereafter

The ICC reviewed the CCTV footage and charged both Warner and de Kock with ‘conduct that brings the game into disrepute.’ Many believed the ICC missed the chance to send a stronger message by imposing harsher penalties. The match referee also reminded both teams of the spirit in which cricket should be played.

Penalties:
 

At the end of the Test, Warner and de Kock shook hands. A Cricket Australia spokesperson said that both team managers — Moosajee and Gavin Dovey — had been spoken to by match referee Jeff Crowe about keeping the players calm.

David Warner: Fined 75% of his match fee and given three demerit points.

Quinton de Kock: Initially fined 50% of his match fee and given two demerit points, later reduced to a 25% fine and one demerit point after appeal.

Warner narrowly avoided suspension, as four demerit points would have triggered a ban, allowing him to play the second Test. Lyon contacted de Villiers overnight to apologize, but he too was fined for a Level 1 offence for conduct contrary to the spirit of cricket.

Aftermath

Also Read: LIVE Cricket Score

The incident reignited discussions about sledging in cricket and the limits of acceptable on-field behavior. It left many wondering whether this was a one-off or part of a pattern of conduct among certain players.